Search Sponsored by

Explore TravelAge West

Destinations

Back
  • Africa & Middle East
  • Asia & South Pacific
  • Caribbean
  • Central & South America
  • Europe
  • Hawaii
  • Mexico
  • USA & Canada

Travel Types

Back
  • Family
  • Adventure
  • Cruise
  • River Cruise
  • Tour Operators
  • Luxury
  • Culinary
  • Romance
  • Wellness
  • Sustainability

Directories

Back
  • Hotels
  • Cruise
  • Job Seeker Center

Interactive

Back
  • Click & Win
  • Geo Quiz
  • Slideshows & Video

Professional Development

Back

Industry Insight

  • Business Features
  • Interviews
  • Events
  • Opinion
  • Tech
  • Humans of Travel Podcast
  • Trade Secrets Podcast
  • Coronavirus and Travel

Education

  • Certifications
  • Digital Guides
  • Fams
  • Thought Leadership
  • Advertiser Spotlight
  • Webinars
  • Immersive Family Experiences

Events

  • Global Travel Marketplace
  • GTM West
  • WAVE Awards
  • Future Leaders in Travel Retreat

Get Us in Your Inbox

I accept the T&C and Privacy Policy.

Search TravelAge West

Clear Field

Share

Overtourism Is Bad—Undertourism Is Worse

Jun 15, 2020
Lindblad 1 hero

Today’s conservation strategies must overtly maximize both biodiversity and the improvement of human well-being simultaneously. Sponsored by Lindblad Expeditions.

Get Us in Your Inbox

I accept the T&C and Privacy Policy.

By Sven Lindblad, Founder & CEO of Lindblad Expeditions

The world is shut. Ninety+ countries have closed their borders. Seventy-five to 100 million people working in tourism are projected to lose their jobs. And trillions of dollars will evaporate from global economies. The overall picture is beyond stunning.

Today, I’d like to focus on what this means for places where nature and tourism intersect—places like Africa’s National Parks and Marine Protected areas; places where nature and wildlife inevitably must pay their way to exist, and where tourism is the ultimate currency protecting nature and wildlife.

We live in a world now totally dominated by humans. Conservation, therefore, is now widely acknowledged to be more than purely supporting biodiversity. Today’s conservation strategies must overtly maximize both biodiversity and the improvement of human well-being simultaneously.

One Hundred to Zero
At press time, it’s now about 3 months into the COVID-19 pandemic, and virtually all the world’s national parks and protected areas are empty. They’re making zero income, and still have costs to maintain systems and pay wages. Many of these protected areas are in countries already strapped financially. Nothing was gradual, nothing could be planned for; it just happened overnight—one hundred to zero.

Midori Paxton, head of Ecosystems and Biodiversity for the United Nations Development Programme (UNDP), writes about Namibia: “Tourism, primarily nature-based, is the second largest economic sector accounting for 15.4% of total employment and 14.7% of the national GDP. Tourism is a core part of the country’s poverty-reduction and biodiversity conservation strategy. One colleague said that community-based tourism is the most effective way to redistribute income from the wealthy to the less wealthy and the poor.”  

Fifty percent of Namibia’s land is designated for conservation-oriented management. The biggest industry is mining. No income from tourism can easily open that door.

During the last decade considerable progress has been made in marine protection (not enough, but accelerated progress). Tourism, and the associated revenue it brings, is a key component, in many instances, for creating the justification for designating marine protected areas (MPAs).

National Geographic Explorer-in-Residence, Enric Sala, launched the Pristine Seas program in 2008 to explore and save the last wild places in the ocean. Pristine Seas has spearheaded the creation of 22 MPAs totaling over 5 million square kilometers of protection. Sala reached out to managers of MPAs involved and there was consensus: no tourism, no presence, no deterrence. “MPAs are suffering from the pandemic in different ways, but the greatest impact has been the sudden drop in tourism revenue which is reducing the ability of MPA managers to enforce many of them,” he says.

The small Pacific island state of Palau or, as I prefer to say, the large ocean state of Palau, is led by a remarkable visionary, President Tommy Remengesau. He is in the final year of his second term as president and three decades of politics. On January 1, 2020, Palau officially declared 80% of its Exclusive Economic Zone (EEZ) to be fully protected; i.e. no extraction of any kind—fishing or mining. This courageous move came after years of planning by local officials and advocates, including Pristine Seas. This represents nearly a half-million square kilometers, making it one of the world’s largest MPAs.

Palau is not easy to get to from the West but, regardless, people come from all over the world to dive and snorkel in this marine paradise. Tourism is by far the main source of income and President Remengesau was looking to strategies that would bring in higher-value tourism. The protection of 80% of Palau’s EEZ meant giving up all revenue from foreign fishing licenses. Tourism in 2020 is projected to decline 52% and even more in 2021. Pressure could mount to open up international fishing again.

Palau is in relatively good shape compared to many Pacific islands. GDP is high and unemployment low. But, above all, Palau has inspired leadership and, as such, is a beacon of hope in the world. Recently President Remengesau delivered his final State of the Republic address to his 22,000 citizens. He said, referring to the various crises the islands have faced, “Through all these adversities, we Palauans have stood tall and together to take whatever actions were necessary to survive the disaster and to persevere into the future and for our children. I guarantee you today that we will once again endure and come out of this crisis more resilient and better prepared going forward.”

I have such personal respect for this president who, when he references future generations, really means it. His legacy, however, will inevitably be shaped by Palau’s ability to return to a healthy tourism industry soon.

Brett Jenks, CEO of Rare and an early pioneer in community ecotourism, is a global leader in catalyzing behavioral change to achieve enduring conservation results. Jenks knows better than most how integral tourism is to enduring conservation results. “Thirty years ago, conservationists all over the world started promoting ecotravel so that people could fall in love with rainforests and coral reefs. This helped build a global constituency for nature. It helped millions of local people find good jobs in tourism, park management, protection, restoration, and guiding” he says. “It’s heart-breaking to imagine no tourism. There is a whole generation of nature-loving entrepreneurs out there, but they won’t survive without tourism, and in some cases, the parks will perish with them.”

Jenks also knows that people who travel and are exposed to the world’s wild places are often the most important donors to NGOs broadly, and certainly to Rare specifically.

And, finally, I asked Peter Knights, CEO of Wild Aid, whose work in fighting illegal wildlife trade is at the forefront of this battle, for his thoughts. “We’re deeply concerned that the pandemic will lead to a poaching crisis,” he says. “No tourism means loss of income for many people; taxi drivers, cleaners, chefs, tourist guides and even Maasai villagers. The lockdowns have caused economic hardship for tens of millions, some of whom may turn to poaching and bushmeat. At the same time, with no tourists or staff, you find way less eyes and ears on the ground in parks and reserves so it’s easier to get in and out undetected. Already there are reports of resurgent rhino poaching in Southern Africa. In the longer run, some anti-poaching efforts, especially on private reserves, depend on tourism for funding and may have to be cut back or even halted. Governments have used tourism revenue to pay for conservation costs. So, without emergency support, things look grim.”

The bottom line: One hundred to zero is a big, big problem. Tourism is far from being a perfect industry; it can do much more than it has to date. Now we can all better understand the implications of zero tourism—and as we build it up again, we must find ways to do it better, wiser, more sustainably. In Chinese, the ideogram for crisis means both danger and opportunity. This is our opportunity. 

Lindblad Expeditions Emphasizes Travel as a Force for Good

Lindblad 1 sidebar

For Sven Lindblad, founder and CEO of Lindblad Expeditions, there’s no question that travel—when properly planned and executed—can be a positive force in the world. “Some may argue that humankind should avoid travel in airplanes, ships or cars to dramatically lessen carbon emissions. I will argue that staying at home in our own bubbles isn’t a viable solution for anyone who wants to engage with the wider world and continue to explore, understand, discover and improve it,” he says. “Which is why our approach to travel—travel that provides people a chance to see the world up close and personal and develop empathy and a real reason to care about its future—is more important now than ever before.”

To that end, Lindblad Expeditions continues to focus on ways to encourage responsible travel, such as the company’s announcement last year to become a carbon-neutral travel company. “We have always had an ethic of conservation across our fleet and offices, but the demand for bigger, bolder and more sustained efforts to combat global climate change is greater now than ever before,” Lindblad says.

Lindblad’s ambitious carbon-neutral program goes far beyond its award-winning expeditions. “Our credits will offset the carbon footprint of our fleet, land-based operations, offices in New York City and Seattle, employee travel and anything else that can be measured,” he notes.  

With its extensive array of conservation programs and sustainability initiatives, Lindblad Expeditions also makes it easy for travelers and travel advisors to get involved in sustainability efforts. A sampling of other sustainability-focused initiatives includes comprehensive single-use plastic elimination program across the entire fleet; a culinary program focused on sustainably produced local products; the world’s first self-disinfecting ships; plastic-free deliveries of parkas and other supply-chain changes, and more.  

In addition to the Lindblad Expeditions-National Geographic alliance, which assures advisors that they’re offering clients quality experiences from some of the industry’s most recognized brands, Lindblad Expeditions has prioritized the idea of inspiring people to explore and care about the planet. In fact, travelers aboard the Lindblad fleet have collectively contributed more than $18.8 million to support stewardship efforts Lindblad Expeditions oversees in partnership with the National Geographic Society. The Lindblad Expeditions-National Geographic (LEX-NG) Fund supports a variety of global initiatives and regional partners aimed at protecting the ocean and fostering environmental stewardship in Alaska, the Amazon, Galapagos, the Arctic and other regions the company visits. Find out more here. 

“Travel is in many ways the world’s classroom,” says Lindblad. “We develop understanding, empathy and new ways of thinking, even living, through travel, not to mention the sheer joy and spiritual awakening it can provide. The key question for all of us to consider is: Do we help our future by traveling or not?”

For Lindblad, the answer is simple: “I believe we should travel, learn, take what we see and hear to heart. I believe we should care and seek creative ways to act on behalf of future generations to protect the world’s beauty, cultures and biodiversity. If we do that, I am convinced, the good will far outweigh any bad. I hope you agree and choose to travel with us and share in the adventure—the celebration of nature, wildlife, and human diversity—that our expeditions are all about.”

For more information about how Lindblad Expeditions is leading the way in creating a better world through travel, go to Expeditions.com/sustainability. 

During the COVID-19 pandemic, TravelAge West will remain a trusted resource for our readers now and long after this crisis is over, and will continue to publish articles on a variety of travel industry topics, destinations and more to inspire future trips. If there’s something you’d like us to cover, please send a message to [email protected]

Tell Us What You Think! forum

  • Most Read
  • Most Shared
  1. How to Get a COVID-19 Test in Mexico
  2. What the COVID-19 Vaccine Means for Travel to Mexico
  3. These Hotels Offer COVID-19 Testing in the Caribbean
  4. How the Marriott Waikiki Collection Balances Safety and Aloha
  5. French Polynesia Is Closing Borders to Tourism
  1. CDC Requires Negative COVID-19 Test for Entry Into the U.S.
  2. French Polynesia Is Closing Borders to Tourism
  3. How to Get a COVID-19 Test in Mexico
  4. Air Tahiti Nui and United Suspend Flights Between the U.S. and French Polynesia
  5. COVID-19 Vaccinations and Travel: Are Senior Citizens Ready to Roam?

More Stories Like This

Lindblad Thought Leadership 4

Travel's Local Impact — What You Can Do to Bring It Back

ALGV_TL_hero

Time to Start Booking Travel Again?

lindblad 3 hero

Regenerative Tourism: Beyond Sustainable Tourism

Lindblad 2 hero

Global Tourism: Opportunity for a Reset?

FamilyBeachVacation_Palladium_Hero

The New Family Beach Vacation

All Aboard!

All Aboard!

TravelAge West

About TravelAge West

  • About Us
  • Contributors
  • Sales Team
  • Contact Us
  • My Profile

Advertise

  • Advertise With Us
  • Media Kit
  • Upload Ad Material
  • Digital Ad Specifications
  • Reprints
  • Subscribe to Print

Stay Connected to TravelAge West

Get Us in Your Inbox

I accept the T&C and Privacy Policy.


Northstar Travel Group

Northstar Travel Group

  • Travel Weekly
  • Travel Weekly Asia
  • Travel Weekly China
  • TravelPulse
  • TravelPulse Canada
  • TravelPulse Quebec
  • Meetings & Incentives
  • Travel Technology
  • Corporate Travel
  • Hotel Investment
  • Data Products
  • AGENTatHOME
Copyright © 2021 by Northstar Travel Media LLC. All Rights Reserved. 100 Lighting Way, Secaucus, NJ 07094-3626 USA | Telephone: (201) 902-2000
Load Carousel Here
Load Video Here